This is the html version of the file http://www.cih.uib.no/journals/EJHD/ejhdv17-no1/ejhdv17-n1-page33.pdf.
G o o g l e automatically generates html versions of documents as we crawl the web.
To link to or bookmark this page, use the following url: http://www.google.com/search?q=cache:x6cvy9knhyQJ:www.cih.uib.no/journals/EJHD/ejhdv17-no1/ejhdv17-n1-page33.pdf+PhD,+Tigray+Health&hl=en&lr=lang_en


Google is not affiliated with the authors of this page nor responsible for its content.
These search terms have been highlighted:  phd  tigray  health 

Page 1
Original article
Health care providers’ perceptions on harmful
traditional health practices in Ethiopia
Anders Jeppsson
1
, Mequanent Tesfu
2
, Lars-Åke Persson
3
Abstract
Background: More knowledge is needed about traditional surgical procedures performed in
African countries, and the complications caused by such practices.
Objective This paper describes the frequency of traditional surgical health practices and their
adverse physical health effects in various regions of Ethiopia, as interpreted by a representative
sample of health workers.
Methods: A list of health practices was presented to 97 health workers sampled from all but 2
regions in Ethiopia. They were asked whether these practices, to their knowledge, were carried out
in their respective catchment areas and whether they had observed any physical complications.
Results: According to the perceptions of the health workers, the frequent practice of female genital
mutilation was confirmed, and in addition practices such as milk tooth extraction, uvulectomy,
uterus massage and tonsillectomy were prevalent. The most commonly reported complications were
infections, followed by bleeding. Most of these traditional surgical procedures resulted in frequent
and sometimes fatal complications.
Conclusions: The findings call for preventive strategies, where the health sector may play an
important role. [Ethio.J.Health Dev. 2003;17(1):35-44]
Background
Traditional surgical practices, like female
genital mutilation, have been performed during
a number of centuries in several geographical
areas (1, 2). Bleeding and cupping were
reported from Ethiopia already during the 19
th
century (3). Other practices may be specific to
one geographical area, e.g. rectal ulceration,
which so far only has been reported from
Ethiopia (4).
1
Department of Community Medicine, Lund
University, Sweden & Department of
Community Health, Mbarara University of
Science and Technology, Mbarara, Uganda; at
the time of the study Family Health
Department, Ministry of Health, Addis Ababa,
Ethiopia;
2
Family Health Department, Ministry
of Health, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia;
3
Division of
Epidemiology, Department of Public Health
and Clinical Medicine, Umea University,
Sweden
In Ethiopia a few studies have assessed the
occurrence of different traditional surgical
procedures (4, 5, 6), but there is still limited
information available about the health workers’
perceptions on possible benefit or harm caused
by these practices (4, 5). The serious health
consequences of female genital mutilation,
which is reportedly performed on a vast
majority of Ethiopian women (5, 7), were more
frequently occurring among those who had
undergone more serious forms of mutilation,
like excision and infibulation (8). In surveys
among health workers in Ethiopia (4, 5) most
interviewees had experience of other traditional
surgical practices from their local communities,
e.g. male circumcision, milk tooth extraction,
tattooing, cauterisation, cupping and scarify-
cation. Procedures like rectal ulceration and
blood letting were less commonly reported,
while uvulectomy and milk tooth extraction
were common in the northern part of the
country. Thus, in addition to female genital

Page 2
36 Ethiop.J.Health Dev.
___________________________________________________________________
mutilation a number of other traditional
surgical procedures are practised in Ethiopia.
There is a need to get more knowledge about
the perceptions of these practices among health
professionals, and experiences of complications
and negative health effects caused by such
procedures. The aim of this paper is therefore to
assess the frequency of surgical health practices
in various regions of Ethiopia, as interpreted by
health workers, to investigate possible adverse
physical health effects, and to discuss possible
means of intervention against harmful
practices.
Methods
This questionnaire-based study was linked to an
Ethiopian reproductive health survey in 1995.
A two stage stratified type of sampling
procedure was used for the study. Accordingly,
all the 11 Ethiopian regions except two were
covered by the study. According to a decision
by the Ministry of Health the regions of Afar
and Benshangul were left out because of a low
number of health facilities.
In the second stage, hospitals, health centres
and number of health stations were randomly
selected from each region (21 hospitals, 25
health centres and 51 health stations). The final
selection of health stations was randomly done
while in the respective regions, since no
registers of health stations were available at
central level. The number of health facilities
selected was based on the total number in the
respective region.
Table 1: Health Facilitates studied
Region
Hospitals
Health centres
Health Stations (number)
Addis Ababa
Yekatit 12
Police
Akaki
Lideta
6
Tigray
Mekele
Axum
Mekele
Tembien
Wukro
6
Amhara
Woldia
Debre Berhan
Dessie
Gonder
Debre Sina
Lalibella
Kenissie
Chilga
Este
Bahar Dar
11
Oromia
Dembidello
Aira
Ambo
Jimma
Asebeteferi
Wollisso
Nekemte
Ziway
Nazret
Assella
Gimbi
Ejaj
Bokoje
Mojale
19
Somali
Jidjiga
Kararda
1
Southern Ethiopia
Attat
Arbaminch
Hossaina
Yirgalem
Sawella
Konteb
Butajira
8
Gambella
Gambela
Itang
1
Harar
Hiwot Fana
Dire Dawa
Del Chora

Page 3
Traditional health practices, surgical procedures, complications, Ethiopia 37
___________________________________________________________________
One knowledgeable staff member from each
health institution was to be selected to answer
the questionnaire. For hospitals and health
centres outpatient department the intention was
to select a nurse, while for the health stations a
health assistant was to be interviewed.
Based on published reports and other available
information at the Family Health Department of
the Ethiopian Ministry of Health a list of
relatively common traditional surgical or other
health care related procedures was created. The
purpose was to assess, whether a link could be
established between a certain set of traditional
practices on one side and medical complication
on the other. Some known practices, like the
insertion of lip-plates, were deliberately left out
since they, although common, were restricted to
certain geographical areas.
The interviewees were asked if they had
experienced such practices within their own
geographical area, if they had observed any
complications, if they perceived any potential
harm and benefit, and possible explanations and
rationale for these surgical procedures. The
interviewees were specifically asked to report
from their own observations and experiences,
and not from general knowledge or perceptions.
They were also asked to suggest actions and
interventions against practices they considered
harmful.
The following traditional practices were
included in the questionnaire:
Female genital mutilation: The most well
known type of traditional surgical practice.
Milk tooth extraction: According to traditional
beliefs diarrhoea and fever at the time of milk
tooth eruption may be due to worms in the gum
(9). This can be dealt with by having the teeth
extracted or, rather, the gum being drilled and
the primary teeth or the new, permanent teeth
extracted or carved out. The practice of milk
tooth extraction is also reported as a treatment
of poorly growing older children (4). This
practice is reported to cause osteitis and
osteomyelitis (6).
Uvulectomy: The uvula is thought to cause
oropharyngeal blockage (6). In addition,
prolonged swelling of the throat, vomiting and
coughing in children as well as in adults are
attributed to an inflamed uvula (10). The uvula
is often snared with a loop-ending string and
then cut with a knife (11). Haemorrhage and
infections, including tetanus, are reported as
complications.
Incision of eye-lid is known as a treatment of
eye diseases, especially as a treatment of eye
infections (4, 6). It is carried out with a razor
blade, and is often resulting in secondary skin
infections and in excessive bleeding (6).
Tonsillectomy: Sore throat, difficulties in
swallowing and coexistence of seizures with
these conditions are often attributed to illness of
the tonsils. The tonsils are sometimes
enucleated by the index finger of the healer
(10). A related practice is scraping a sore throat
with a long finger nail (9). Bleeding indicates
the success of the operation. Haemorrhage,
infection, suffocation and death are known
complications.
Blood-letting through vein puncture on scalp
(wagemt). The rationale behind blood-letting is
that the body is decaying internally, causing
tissue swelling and deteriorating health. This
can be dealt with by removing blood. It is
especially prescribed for elephantiasis,
rheumatism, high fever and headache (11).
Travellers to Ethiopia have described bleeding
techniques since ancient times (3, 4).

Page 4
38 Ethiop.J.Health Dev.
___________________________________________________________________
Venesection on arms (mognebegegne). Besides
the rationale for bleeding techniques described
above, venesection has also been described as a
treatment for meningitis. Also arteries are
sometimes stabbed to get blood out of the
patients (4).
Cauterisation (tattate):
Ailments such as
conjunctivitis, headache, ear infections,
tuberculosis and bone fractures are sometimes
treated with cauterisation (burning with hot
matter). In the highlands it is also used for joint
pains. The rationale is the belief that intense
heat destroys the pathogenic substance inside
the body. Although the modalities of the
procedure differ, it is usually carried out with
hot charcoals, a hot iron or a burning stick (11).
Uterus massage: Kneading and squeezing a
woman’s abdomen with the intent to massage
the uterus, is a widely used practice to induce
labour. It may prolong labour and cause
bleeding and uterus rupture (9).
Rectal ulceration: The practice of rectal
ulceration is known as a treatment of whip-
worm (Trichuris trichiura) (4). It is reportedly
also carried out as a treatment against
diarrhoea. Little information is available on this
practice.
Ethical clearance for the study was obtained
from the Ministry of Health. Informed consent
was obtained from all participating health
personnel. Data were stored and processed by
use of Epi Info epidemiological software (12).
Results
Overall 97 interviews were undertaken. In a
few cases it was not possible to visit the health
units selected due to logistical problems. 51
health assistants were interviewed at the
selected health stations. Out of the remaining
46 interviewees, the vast majority were nurses,
with the exception of a few physicians.
What kinds of practices are undertaken in this
area?
The interviewed health personnel recognised
that most of the listed traditional surgical
procedures were being performed in their own
areas.
Uvulectomy was concentrated as previously
shown, to the northern parts of Ethiopia,
although it seems to be common in most areas
of the country. The practice was neither
reported from Somali nor from Gambella.
Female genital mutilation is practiced in most
areas in the country. As previously known,
Gambella is one exception. Slightly surprising
is that the reported frequency is not higher in
Tigray. Other authors have attributed high
prevalence to this region.
Rectal ulceration is, as previously reported, not
one of the most common practices, but does
exist in some regions, with a focus in the
eastern part of Ethiopia.
The practice of milk tooth extraction is
frequent, and reported from all areas surveyed.
All surveyed regions reported that this practice
was carried out.
Little is found in the literature on eye-lid
incision, and although it is not one of the most
common traditional practices, the study showed
that the practice in being carried out all over the
country, with the exceptions of Gambella,
Somali and Dire Dawa. Is also found to be
rather frequent, especially in the north (Tigray)
and in Harrar. There is a very uneven
distribution of the practice over the country.
There is a concentration of vein puncture to
Tigray, Amhara and Oromia, i e in the northern
and central parts of the country. The occurrence
in Addis Ababa may be due to a strong
influence of these ethnic groups.

Page 5
Traditional health practices, surgical procedures, complications, Ethiopia 39
___________________________________________________________________
Table 2: Occurrence of harmful traditional practices by region, as recalled by health personnel
Type of traditional practice
Total
Tigray
Amhara
Oromia Somali
Southern Gambella
Harrar
Addis
Ababa
Dire
Dawa
Uvulectomy
80
82.5%
11
20
25
0
13
0
1
9
1
Female genital mutilation
72
74.2%
4
18
28
2
13
0
1
5
1
Milk tooth extraction
84
86.6%
10
18
27
2
13
3
1
9
1
Rectal ulceration
5
5.2%
0
2
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
Incision of eye-lid
32
33.0%
11
6
7
0
5
0
1
2
0
Vein puncture on arms to get rid
of illness (mognebegegne)
33
34.2%
9
15
6
1
0
0
0
2
0
Blood letting through vein
puncture on scalp (wagemt)
25
25.8%
7
7
3
2
2
1
0
2
1
Tonsillectomy
53
54.6%
3
11
17
2
12
0
1
6
1
Cauterization (Tattate) treatment
by burn with an iron rod
50
51.5%
9
8
16
2
10
0
0
4
1
Birth practices, uterus massage 56
57.7%
9
10
18
1
11
1
1
5
0
Number of health workers
surveyed (n)
97
11
21
32
2
17
3
1
9
1
The distribution of blood letting on the scalp
shows a slightly different pattern than
venesection on the arms. Still frequent in the
highlands (Amhara and Tigray), it is even more
frequent in the west (Dire Dawa and Somali).
Tonsillectomy is common in most areas of the
country with Gambella as the single exception.
It is overall very common.
Cauterization (burning of the skin by hot
matter, e g an iron rod) seems to be most
common in the west (Dire Dawa and Somali).
As previously shown, it is also very common in
Tigray, Oromia and Amhara.
The practice of uterus massage is common all
over Ethiopia. Harrar reveals the highest
frequency.
Have you observed any adverse health effects
from these practices?
If a health worker reported about a certain
traditional health practice being undertaken in

Page 6
40 Ethiop.J.Health Dev.
___________________________________________________________________
Table 3: Complications due to harmful traditional practices if known to be practised in the
area, as recalled by health personnel
Type of harmful traditional practice
Frequency
Milk tooth extraction
100%
Rectal ulceration
100%
Incision of eye-lid
100%
Birth practices, uterus massage
98%
Female genital mutilation
98%
Cauterization (Tattate) treatment by burn with an iron rod
97%
Uvulectomy
95%
Tonsillectomy
95%
Blood letting through vein puncture on scalp (wagemt)
94%
Vein puncture on arms to get rid of illness (mognebegegne)
90%
Number of health workers surveyed (n)
97
the catchment area, the same health worker was
asked whether he or she had observed
complications due to the practice in question.
We are now dealing with first level
information, i.e the experience of the health
workers themselves.
As indicated above, the reporting of observed
complications due to traditional practices were
overall high. All investigated practices
reportedly resulted in high complication rates.
The interviewees were asked specifically in
what way the practices were harmful, and what
particular kinds of complications they had
observed.
Table 4: Health personnel’s report on the complications observed to traditional surgical procedures in
their own area in Ethiopia (n=97)
Traditional practice
Most common complications
Milk tooth extraction
Infection, even tetanus and sepsis, bleeding, damage of permanent teeth
Uvulectomy
Infection (even sepsis, tetanus, HIV), bleeding, death
Female genital mutilation
Bleeding, infection, delivery complications, anaemia, death
Uterus massage
Rupture of uterus, maternal death, bleeding, stillbirth, foetal distress, bladder
rupture, abruption of placenta
Tonsillectomy
Infection (including tetanus), bleeding, breast feeding difficulties, death
Cauterisation
Infection (also tetanus), scar formation, nerve paralysis
Venopuncture
Severe bleeding, anaemia, infection, HIV, death
Incision of eye-lid
Infection, scar, bleeding,
Rectal ulceration
Damage of sphincter, rectal prolapse, bleeding, infection
In short, all the surveyed practices seemed to
have hazardous effects to health. This was the
clear message obtained from the interviewees.
Other types of traditional practices mentioned
with complications
In addition to the checklist with practices
presented to the health workers, the health
workers were asked to identify other harmful
traditional practices undertaken in the
catchment area. They were also asked what
type of complications that are normally
presented as a result of the practice in question.

Page 7
Traditional health practices, surgical procedures, complications, Ethiopia 41
___________________________________________________________________
The information obtained for other types of
health practices deemed harmful by the
interviewees, was based on open-ended
questions. Hence there is no clear focus on
surgical or skin-piercing practices. All types of
health practices are included. It is interesting to
see that a few practices that appear here, like
uncleanness in conjunction with umbilicus care,
result in serious complications like tetanus.
Table 5: Type of traditional practices mentioned with complications.
Type of practice
Complications
Frequency
Removal of nails
Drinking local kosso (taenicide) on wedding day
Ticked, but not specified
1
Herbs
Loss of weight
1
Subsequent risks
1
Body rash
1
Epigastric pain
2
Diarrhea
1
Hepatitis
1
Early starting of food < 4 months like butter, cow milk
Malnutrition
Infections & parasites
1
Incision of glands
Bleeding
Anemia
Infection
1
Application of herbs on burn wounds
Infection
Fever
Septicemia
1
Dung on the umbilicus
Tetanus
2
Mud on the umbilicus
Tetanus
1
Tenkway (professional sorcery)
Impaired health
Death
1
Sucking blood
HIV risk
1
According to the opinions expressed by the
participating health workers the frequent
practice of these traditional surgical procedures
had its roots in ignorance, and lack of
information on western medical views on
appropriate
treatment.
Illiteracy
was
specifically mentioned as a contributing factor.
A group of answers focused on explanations
related to traditional values and influence from
tradition keepers in society, especially religious
and community leaders, ‘.... this has been going
on for generations’. Another level of
explanation focused the lack of access to
modern health care, or the lack of quality of
care, leaving the individual without realistic
alternatives to traditional treatments. Finally,
the respondents stated that traditional health
practices were not under the supervision by the
authorities, presumably making this a more
attractive alternative.
The health workers suggested increased health
education to various groups in the community
in order to reduce the practice of these harmful
procedures. In addition, an intensified
discussion with religious and community
leaders was given priority. Training of
community health workers and traditional birth
attendants was also mentioned, as well as other
ways of improving the collaboration between
the health workers and the community. The
prevalent performance of harmful practices also
called for improvements in the service provided
by health facilities in rural areas. Finally, some
health workers wanted the government to
increase the control of the traditional practices
in the country.
Discussion
This study has demonstrated that a number of
traditional
surgical
interventions
was
commonly practised in Ethiopia, and frequently

Page 8
42 Ethiop.J.Health Dev.
___________________________________________________________________
resulting in serious and life-threatening
complications. The frequent practice of female
genital mutilation was confirmed, and in
addition practices such as milk tooth extraction,
uvulectomy, uterus massage and tonsillectomy
were prevalent. The focus of the study is not to
confirm the existence of the traditional
practices in question, but rather to explore the
medical complications in an Ethiopian context.
The study aimed at establishing whether the
listed procedures were practised or not in the
different geographical areas, and not the level
of occurrence in the population as such. The
strategically
selected
health
workers,
representing different areas in proportion to the
size of the areas, may be an appropriate source
of information for that type of question. They
were specifically asked to report from their own
observations and experiences, and not only
from general knowledge or perceptions. Thus,
the information obtained is probably reflecting
if these traditions are implemented in the areas,
and if complications have been observed at the
health institutions. The findings are applicable
to the Ethiopian context, but may also be
relevant in other cultural settings, whenever the
prevalence of disability, occurrence of death
and costs linked to harmful traditional practices
are discussed.
We have demonstrated that drastic surgical and
other traditional procedures, e g uterus
massage, were performed in many areas of
Ethiopia. While studies on traditional health
practices previously have focused female
genital mutilation, other customs affecting
women and children have received little
attention. Several of the listed practices, e.g.
uvulectomy and milk tooth extraction, were
found in most geographical areas, while others,
like rectal ulceration, were more geographically
restricted.
It should be noted, that HIV was reported as an
observed complication to two of the practices
(uvulectomy and venesection). To our
knowledge, this has not been previously shown,
and the finding warrants further in-depth
studies.
Whereas a number of authors have described
the frequency and the complications of female
genital mutilation (1, 5, 8) information on other
types of drastic surgical practices are more
based on individual case reports rather than
larger surveys. This study covers some of the
major drastic surgical interventions throughout
most of Ethiopia. The reports on occurrence of
these practices confirm previous case reports
that we have found. In addition, we have found
that these practices often result in
complications adverse to health, an observation
that may seem logical, but previously
overlooked. The overall conclusion from this
study is that the practices in question seem to
be common and, more importantly that
resulting complications also seem to be
frequent. It should be noted, that only few
interviewees mentioned the risk of spreading
infections through surgical practices. In a time
when serious chronic infections, like HIV and
hepatitis are prevalent, there is reason to
address issue more specifically.
Lack of health facilities and modern health
services may contribute to the performance of a
number of traditional surgical health practices,
but maybe not to female genital mutilation,
since the latter is usually not perceived as being
related to health (13, 14). A recent study in
rural Ethiopia reported a low usage of health
care in spite of a huge burden of perceived,
indicating large unmet needs facing the health
delivery system (15). In a milieu where modern
health care is not available, decisions
concerning health are influenced by the fact
that people must create different ways to handle
disease. This further means that different
models for explaining disease are naturally
created and maintained.
In a longer perspective, a transformation of the
Ethiopian society is likely to bring a change to

Page 9
Traditional health practices, surgical procedures, complications, Ethiopia 43
___________________________________________________________________
these practices. However, such a transformation
cannot be considered a prerequisite for change.
That would rather be an excuse for not
addressing these issues. An improved coverage
of the health services will probably contribute
to a reduced importance of traditional practices
and consequently reduce the practice of
harmful traditional surgical procedures. This
will be a process where peoples’
conceptualisation about health is likely to
change, and concepts of modern medicine will
be incorporated in people’s perception of health
and disease. The issue is not only the provision
of modern medical care, but also to promote a
change in knowledge and perception of health
and disease.
References
1. Koso-Thomas O: The Circumcision of
Women. A Strategy for Eradication.
London and New Jersey: Zed Books Ltd.;
1987.
2. Rushwan H, Slot C J M, Dareer A &
Bushra N: Female Circumcision in the
Sudan.
Prevalence,
Complications,
Attitudes and Change. A Report of a study
conducted by the Faculty of Medicine,
University of Khartoum, Sudan (1977-
1982). Khartoum: Faculty of Medicine,
University of Khartoum, Sudan; 1983.
3. Pankhurst R: An historical examination of
traditional Ethiopian medicine and surgery.
Ethiop Med J 1965;3:157-171.
4. Haile Meskal F, Kefene H, Haile Selassie
A & Khodakevich L: A Survey on
Harmful Traditional Practices in Ethiopia;
Mimeo, 1990.
5. Gebre Selassie A, Desta M & Negash Z.
Harmful Traditional Practices Affecting
the Health of Women and Children in
Ethiopia. Addis Ababa: Ministry of Health
& Unicef; 1985.
6. Dagnew M B & Damena M. Traditional
child health practices in communities in
north-west Ethiopia. Tropical Doctor 1990
January: 40-41.
7. National Committee on Traditional
Practices in Ethiopia (NCTPE), FGM
Occurrence and prevalence, Final report,
Baseline Survey on Harmful Traditional
practices in Ethiopia, Addis Ababa,
September 1998.
8. Dejene A, Gudunffa A, Agere F & Segne
T. Complications of female
genital
mutilation (FGM) during labor and
delivery in two regions in Ethiopia.
Mimeo; 1995.
9. Ministry of Health, Dept. of Family Health
& National Committee on Harmful
Traditional Practices, Ethiopia. Workshop
Report on Elimination of Harmful
Traditional Practice Affecting the Health
of Mothers and Children. Addis Ababa:
Tesfa Printing Press; 1988.
10. Abdullah M A: ‘Traditional practices and
other socio-cultural factors affecting the
health of children in Saudi Arabia’.
Annals of Tropical Paediatrics 1993;13:
227-232.
11. Vecchiato N L. Traditional Medicine. In
Kloos H & Zein A Z. The Ecology of
Health and Disease in Ethiopia. Boulder:
Westview Press; 1993:169-170.
12. Dean AD, Dean JA, Burton AH, Dicker
RC. EpiInfo, Version 5: a word processing,
database and statistics program for
epidemiology on micro-computers. USD,
Incorporate, Stone Mountain, Georgia,
1990.
13. Negussie B: Traditional Wisdom and
Modern Development. A Case Study of

Page 10
44 Ethiop.J.Health Dev.
___________________________________________________________________
Peri-Natal Knowledge among elderly
Women in Southern Shewa, Ethiopia. PhD
Dissertation. Studies in Comparative and
International Education No. 13. Institute of
International Education, University of
Stockholm, 1988.
14. Dirie
M,
Lindmark
G:
Female
Circumcision in Somalia and Women’s
motives. Acta Obstet Geynecol Scand
1991;70:582-585.
15. Shifteraw, T. Illness burden and use of
health services in a rural community,
southwestern Ethiopia. East. Afr. Med. J.
1993;70:717-20.

Page 11
Traditional health practices, surgical procedures, complications, Ethiopia 45
___________________________________________________________________